← Back
Vine Street Cafe

Hamptons · Shelter Island

Vine Street Cafe

#34 in HamptonsAmerican$$$

Awards

4.6

What People Are Saying

“We had our micro wedding reception of 8 people in their smaller private room and it was perfect! They offered to set up the decorations that we dropped off the night before and did a great job; it was beautiful. The beef and tuna tacos, pea soup, bee...”

Mychaela Navel

Mychaela Navel

4 months ago

Google Reviews

New Buzz

The East Hampton Star

News for Foodies 05.29.25

The East Hampton Star · 1 year ago

Eater New York

West Village Is Getting a Restaurant from Popular Shelter Island Chefs

Eater New York · 8 years ago

More coverage →

HRL Ranking

#9#21#32#44
Jul 20Aug 17Sep 14Oct 12

What to Order

Tuna Tacos

Mentioned by multiple reviewers as a standout. Order them as a starter alongside the house bread, which arrives hot and earns its own praise.

Reserve a Table
hotrestaurantlist.comData updated weekly.