Hamptons · Sag Harbor

The American Hotel

Name: The American Hotel
Address: Hamptons, NY, US
Price range: $$$$

#45 in HamptonsFrench-American$$$$

Awards

4.5

What People Are Saying

“We experienced exceptional service and a delightful luncheon on June 2, 2026, at The American Hotel restaurant in Sag Harbor. Our server, Valentina, provided outstanding service, and the culinary offerings were prepared to perfection. Our selections...”

New Buzz

The Hamptons After Labor Day: 8 Luxury Places Still Worth the Drive

Haute Living · 3 weeks ago

The Ultimate Resy Guide to the Hamptons

Resy | Right This Way · 2 months ago

More coverage →

HRL Ranking

Jul 20Aug 17Sep 14Oct 12

What to Order

Lobster Risotto

The Lobster Risotto is the dish guests single out most. Pair it with a bottle from the hotel's legendary 17,000-bottle wine list.

Reserve a Table